Wednesday, July 21, 2021

Weaponizing moral theology against accountability.

Whatever the pious intent, that's the effect of hot-take arguments like this.

On the one hand, technically I can see the argument. 

On the other hand, to paraphrase the late Rick James: "Clericalism is a helluva drug." 

Using moral theology to prevent clerical accountability--especially given the probability that the compulsive sex maniac monsignor got it on with underage boys--is a particularly gross flex.

In Italy, the United States, and Ireland, at least seven priests and deacons in recent years have been arrested or faced charges after using hookup apps to meet or solicit minors for sex, solicit child pornography selfies from minors, or blackmail and extort minors who provided child pornography. 

Grindr and similar apps have come under fire in recent years among child protection advocates, who say that because the apps prioritize anonymity and confidentiality without doing enough to screen users for age, they have become a frequent point of contact between minors and adults interested in soliciting pornographic photographs or meeting for sexual encounters. In some cases, minors are marketed for prostitution through hookup apps, sometimes by adult pimps, studies have found.

The age of consent varies among states. In 13 states the age of consent is 18, but in many others, including Nevada and Maryland, it is 16. In the Church’s penal law, a minor is classified as anyone under the age of 18, and sexual contact below that age is treated as a reserved delict, or major crime, in canon law. 

The Grindr app says it does not permit minors to use the platform, and it requires users to input a date of birth while creating a profile. But, beyond a user-supplied date of birth, the app does not require users to prove they are over 18.

In fact, most companies that own dating and hookup apps “are not doing anything for age verification,” Dani Pinter, senior legal counsel at the National Center on Sexual Exploitation, told The Pillar.

While technology exists to verify the ages of app users easily, most hookup apps “don't ask for ID for any of the dating apps. I mean, you just check a box or enter a birth date, which you can fake. They don't check,” Pinter said.

Failure to ensure that children aren’t permitted to use hookup apps and other online sites used by adults leads to the exploitation, extortion, and trafficking of minors, she added.

Even on apps and social media platforms “where it’s pretty clear that commercial sex acts are happening,” Pinter said, “they don’t verify age.”

The National Center on Sexual Exploitation lobbies and litigates to hold tech companies to a higher standard. 

But Pinter said it’s an uphill battle, and that, in her view, tech companies place profit ahead of stopping the potential victimization of children. 

“The tech industry writ large, including apps and social media platforms, operate on volume and definitely put profits over people,” she said.

Because of loose federal regulations, “they’re not even worried about the consequences.”

Among those consequences, Pinter said, is the widespread grooming of minors by adults on social media, dating, and location-based hookup apps, extortion schemes, and commercial sex trafficking of minors through location based hookup apps. 

The use of location-based hookup apps by minors is a growing phenomenon.

In a 2018 Northwestern University study of 14 to 17 year old males who identify as gay or bisexual, more than half of participants said they used hookup apps for the purposes of meeting partners. Nearly 70% of adolescent participants who said they used such apps did so in order to “meet men in person for sex,” the study concluded. Fifty-one percent of the adolescent participants endorsed using Grindr, and overall, more than a quarter of the study’s adolescent participants said they had had sex with a partner met through an app.

Corrupt businesses do the same thing, protecting their own to protect the brand, and I'm sick of it. 

It is vile to the nth degree coming from what's billed as the Church of Christ.

And again, allegedly full-spectrum Catholics: demanding the coverup of more-than-possible-to-likely-sex-with-underage-boys in the name of detraction....

.....Did you just wake from a forty-year coma?

If so, let me help you get up to speed:

The Diocese of Norwich [Connecticut] said Thursday it is the 31st and most recent Catholic religious organization in the U.S. to seek bankruptcy protection under Chapter 11.

When a conservative Harvard professor and America's most public Jesuit choose the institution instead of accountability, giving a pass to exploitative tech companies in the process, you know where you should be: 

Way over on the other side.

6 comments:

  1. I think Archb Gomez was extremely poor in his commentary. That said, the problem few seem to notice is how investigators conduct themselves. It would be one thing if the Grindr app discovery was released to the man's superiors and they did nothing. It would be a problem if they checked on other celebrity clergy and gave, say, Fr Z or Fr Altman or Fr Dwight L a pass on some juicy info.

    Draco was also outraged when he was out of bed to tattle on Harry and friends and given detention as well. When we're talking culturewar, it might be that every advantage to be scratched out must be done and made widely public. If there are two or more bad actors in this episode, by all means, let's out them all and level appropriate criticism widely instead of selectively.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Selective disclosure and reporting would be grim, indeed--if there were a shred of evidence that the reporter did so. Do you have any?

    It would be great if people fretting over the reporting could cite something actually wrong with it, instead of just imputing motives.

    I mean, this guy was ordained when Burke ran La Crosse and served parishes there for years. Quite the failure of vetting and monitoring there from a Noted Champion of Orthodoxy. But oddly, not even that matters. Pillar probably biased, so full stop.

    https://www.stevenspointjournal.com/story/news/2021/07/20/wisconsin-priest-resigns-national-post-amid-misconduct-allegations/8029433002/

    That the Catholic so-called authorities deem resignation sufficient, and have expressed no interest in doing anything further, tells us that figurative butt-covering omerta is still the order of the day--especially when it involves priests literally uncovering theirs.

    If the laity are willing to buy in, then they deserve everything that follows from the corruption of the institution.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Also, the Pillar issued a statement explaining the genesis of the story and how they proceeded.

    ReplyDelete
  4. It's the basic problem with gossip: one revelation is selective by definition. Do they make a cottage industry of it? I think I've mentioned the problem with it: they didn't go to the man's superiors. They spread scandal by the very act of reporting it widely. They were participants, though perhaps on a level different from sex out of bounds.

    The man in question is attached to a diocese, and therefore his ordinary is responsible for his situation once he has resigned from an out-of-diocese assignment. Technically, this becomes an HR issue, and I don't really need to know if his bishop has suspended him, sent him on retreat, or whatever. And neither do you or anyone else.

    All that said, I wouldn't be inclined to give Archb Gomez a pass on this at all. His response was milquetoast.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Didn't go to the man's superiors? He was detached to the USSCB and the Pillar went to them first. And all the data related to his time while so functioning.

    But I'm starting to see why the pontiff spent all that time on gossip: to teach the bishops to how to protect the vulnerable.

    Namely, the Zanchettas and Burrills.

    And if you report on it, it's detraction.

    But you don't need to know what the bishop does with him, serfs, because it's HR. And you can trust CathInc. to do the right thing. Even when their first instinct is to issue statements showing they haven't learned anything.

    And the networks of corruption and mutually-assured job destruction which enable it are left untouched. So all of the corrupt can sleep somewhat easier.

    Somewhere in the undiscovered country, Richard Sipe is saying "I warned them. I really did." Yes, you did. And those in power understood you perfectly--and made sure to keep protecting themselves first last and always.

    I didn't think I'd see you of all people become a company man, Todd. But here we are.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Actually, it's not detraction. It's gossip. The former involves lies. This report, apparently, was the truth.

      FWIW, I don't make the company rules. Bishops listen to lawyers and accountants. And rich lay people. I just describe what I see. I might not agree with it, and perhaps you don't, but there we have it.

      But if it makes you happy, let me state Fr Burrill has fallen into grave sin by misusing his sexuality and forsaking his vows. If his bishop asked me to join a board of lay people, I would interview the man and ask his intentions. I think that board could include the bishop, but I think adding priests would be a bad idea. After knowing him, I might recommend his laicization. I think the renunciation of his pension should be on the table. If he decided to remain in the priesthood, certainly he needs to go on a thirty-day retreat to focus himself for final years of service. He probably shouldn't be living alone, or managing money or personnel, or saying Mass for a period of time, public or private, and he certainly needs to make some public act of satisfaction. Not knowing the man's state of mind, it's hard to get into specifics. I suspect some "faithful" Catholics would want him publicly humiliated in some way. I'd hope they weren't on the board.

      Delete

Be reasonably civil. Ire alloyed with reason is fine. But slagging the host gets you the banhammer.

New digs for ponderings about Levantine Christianity.

   The interior of Saint Paul Melkite Greek Catholic Church, Harissa, Lebanon. I have decided to set up a Substack exploring Eastern Christi...